When a buyer chooses the cheapest option, they are rarely doing so enthusiastically. In most cases, they are defaulting to a safe choice they can justify to their board. Price is an objective criterion that requires no technical expertise to defend. Quality is subjective unless it can be proven.
Most SME decision-makers are not cybersecurity experts. When they evaluate MSPs, they hear the same claims from everyone. They want to make the right decision but have no reliable way to assess who is actually better. In the absence of evidence, the safest choice is the cheapest one.
Buyers need to be confident enough to defend their choice. If they choose the more expensive provider and something goes wrong, they will be asked why they paid more. Without evidence, they cannot answer that question. With evidence, they can.
Stop asking buyers to trust you. Start showing them evidence they can verify independently. The MSPs that win at premium prices are not necessarily the best - they are the ones best at proving they are the best.